I planted them all at once and still no trophy. Have waited for them to grow again and still nothing. Going to try and move the crop plot to the middle of the island and see what happens and I have them on the outside edge on the beach. I’ll keep you posted
I appreciate you trying different methods out and letting me know how you get on Lore, if the team have any more suggestions I shall be sure to share them too
Not been able to test. My son is sick. I’ll test when able
No rush at all Loreweaver! I hope your son feels better soon 
Have tried everything including starting a new save thinking it my main save was just bugged but still no trophy. Even went so far as to make sure no other plants were growing wild on the island. Also, can confirm sharks clipping into the terrain, just got bit and drug from a goblin shark that I watched go into then out of the terrain. As for my son, he’s feeling better. Wife and I noticed he’s cutting his 2yr molars. Thank you for the concern.
Aw no, teething is never fun! Glad to hear he’s feeling better though.
Thank you for that detailed update and giving me a rundown on what you’ve tried and any extra checks you did. I’ll update my report for the team. We did a quick trial run and didn’t find an issue on our end but there must be something more here (or it doesn’t effect everyone).
And of course one final check that you’re using an Aloe, Ajuga, Kura, Pip i, Potatoes, Quwawa and Wavulavula along with the new Yucca?
I too could not get this trophy with an existing save so I started a 2nd save with a new world and I was able to get the trophy to pop. I planted all 8 crops as you noted above.
Thanks for noting that NLGpro - this means the issue may be with saves that were updated. I’ll let the team know.
Yep. All plants planted. Even tried 2 of each with no luck
Thanks for the update Loreweaver, I’ll update the team as soon as I can.
Logged on to work on my base a bit, trophy popped up after I harvested 2 yucca plants. I dont know why but I guess maybe because I hadn’t harvested those 2 yucca plants in awhile it didnt recognize I had em planted??
Interesting…
First of all - I’m glad you got the achievement! But something I want to keep an eye on for sure. Thank you for letting me know!
Hi @Clare,
I thought this might be helpful. I have been having the exact same issue getting this trophy and have tried many things and it just popped for me:
What I tried that didn’t work:
- I originally had 11 potato plots (made of corrugated scrap). I replanted 7 of them with all the other plants, plus I added 4 new plots for the Yucca
- I added 8 new beds that have never been planted on my home island
- I went to a new island and tried #2.
Note: this was all done on a previous save from before the 2009 update. Not on any custom islands. On the PS4. I did not try with a new save.
What Worked:
I had actually given up on the trophy and had been away from my island exploring for several days. When I got back, all my plants were dead (the original plots from #1 above). I waited a couple days for rain (that will usually bring them back to life) but it didn’t work this time. I replanted all 15 plots using the spoiled plants from those plots (except for the yucca, I had to get new fruit). This included 4 potato, 4 yucca, and one of everything else. Once I planted the last plots (Yucca). The trophy pooped for me. I didn’t even have to wait for them to grow.
Thank you Kate for that detailed description of your experience, I really appreciate you adding to this. I’ll pass this onto the team too so they can use it in their investigation and own testing
Never worked for me either. Hard mode on starting island. Tried first with wood plots planted each as I got them from other islands. After it didn’t work I cleared them all and replanted. Didn’t work. Then tried using plank plots … planted one after another as shown in image. Still haven’t worked.
Wait for Them to grow I guess
You cannot be on your starter island… Easy fix… go to neighboring island and try there. It worked for me no problem 
2 Likes
Hi Noktavontavius, Welcome to the forums.
I’m sorry to hear this issue has occured for you in your save. We have a known issues report on it here: [Known Issue] "Who Needs the Sea Anyway?" Trophy Unlocking Issues which contains some workarounds including the one Dank-a-licous mentioned about traveling to a new island and planting there one after another.
If you continue to have issues please post a new bug report with as many details as possible in the Console Bug Reports section. We ask players to avoid reviving older posts as sometimes there’s newer information available and it also prevents your report getting missed in a comments section Thank you!
I got this today, I destroyed all my plots with all 8 plants then rebuilt all 8 corrugated metal plots and replanted all fresh crops that I picked right before I destroyed all of them. On my home base with no trees left with no coconuts. The trophy popped right after I planted the last plant. All my plots were not close to touching each other also.
Hi Batman, welcome to the forums!
Thank you for posting your experience of this issue and what worked for you! I shall add it to our Known Issues post (linked in my last message above) as other players may also find this workaround helpful!